So I think the current award are all sort of uncreative, so here are the icons that I think should replace the current award.
Rune Dart - Gained by having your thread stuck.
Attack Cape(t) - Gained by accurate reports.
Berserker Ring - Gained by speaking your mind.
Antifire Shield - Gained by keeping your cool when flamed.
Donator - Gained by donating to the site - Stay as is
RSC Christmas Cracker - Gained by being an original founding member.
Dragon Claws - Gained by being a truly amazing member.
Mages Book - Gained by providing RF with a outstanding idea.
Firecape - Gained by excessive flaming. - Stay as is
Quest Cape - Gained by having unmatched marketplace knowledge.
Staff of Iban - Gained by your amazing knowledge of hacking accounts.
Blue Partyhat - Stay as is
Rune Defender - Gained by always looking out for your fellow members.
Sweets - Stay as is
Jug of Wine - Is this award really needed?
I realized some of the items are bigger/smaller/have background, but they were the best I could find at the time. Please give some feedback, this took a good hour to compile.