• Welcome to ForumKorner!
    Join today and become a part of the community.

Twilight Saga,which is better, book or film version?

Edger20

Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2011
Posts
363
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
I have read the first Twilight saga book but wasn't able to read the sequel and to make up for this, I watch the film version. If I am to compare, I think both book versions are better than the film versions, how about you, which do you prefer and think better, The book or the film?
 

npadk

Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2011
Posts
196
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
I think the movies better, simply because we can feel more of the story thanks to the visuals and acting.
 

cursedsoul

Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2011
Posts
307
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
Movies are better. Reasons:
1) Books get way too drab towards the end. Especially books 3 and 4. And book 2 in the middle.
2) Movies have Robert Pattinson and Taylor Lautner. Enough said.
 

deathpwnag3

Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2011
Posts
22
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
I never watched or read either one but you cant ever.comlare.the book to the movie. The movie is made just like the book but they add more things to make it look good on the screen

My bad fo myself im using an android phone
 

jhoanne26

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2011
Posts
108
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
I prefer the movie rather than the book haha.. the book is well versed but sometimes it's hard to picture them on your mind. in the movie, i think everything is there ahaha..
 

grazmd

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2011
Posts
254
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
I like the book better because it is described and elaborated better than the movies. Books and books made into movies are two different entities. Sometimes what you have read in the book isnt what you expect in the movie. The producer or the director have also their ideas of their own which are different form the author. They only base it on the book what it's not really the book per se. Also when doing movies, there are some parts in the book which are not found in the film. Except for the dragging parts, I still say that Twilight books are better than its movie creations.
 

grazmd

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2011
Posts
254
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
I like the book better because it is described and elaborated better than the movies. Books and books made into movies are two different entities. Sometimes what you have read in the book isnt what you expect in the movie. The producer or the director have also their ideas of their own which are different form the author. They only base it on the book what it's not really the book per se. Also when doing movies, there are some parts in the book which are not found in the film. Except for the dragging parts, I still say that Twilight books are better than its movie creations.
 

courtknee525

Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2011
Posts
178
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
The books for sure are much better than the movies. They get really detailed about everything and you know exactly what's going on. And you can imagine your own characters from the descriptions in the book. The acting in the movies is horrible, Kristen Stewart has no expression and can't for anything. Also, the movies skip out on a lot of important details that are covered in the book. When the movies came out, they were kind of disappointing just because of the acting and the way the actors seemed so strained and set up when they were acting. They didn't do a good job of "being in the moment" and making it seem natural.
 

darkbakshi

Active Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2011
Posts
642
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
I prefer the movie version than the book because I'm way too lazy in reading I would rather lay my back on my sofa grab the remote and turned the TV and DVD on and watched it.
 

vignesssh

Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2011
Posts
128
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
i dont have any patience to read the books, so i always watch movies which gets over within 1.30 to 2.30 hrs
 

ashley528

Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2011
Posts
218
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
I like the film better. I want to see them in action. The book was okay of course. I just want to see the characters come alive.
 

teacherwave624

Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2011
Posts
39
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
0
I like the most is the book. I have read all four books of the Twilight. I have collected them all. Though I have watched the movies as well. It is best that the you have read the book to have a little background of the story especially with the short second life of Bree Tanner featured in Eclipse.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register