Was Jesus Really Crucified?

[ehsanji]

According to Christians, 2000 years ago the Crucifixion of Jesus took place and he was resurrected on the third day.
Resurrection, according to the new testimonial, means the rising of Christ on the third day after the Crucifixion.

Crucifixion means ‘the act of executing by a method widespread in the ancient world; the victim's hands and feet are bound or nailed to a cross’.

According to Islam, Jesus was sent by Allah, to the people of Israel, with a scripture called ‘Injeel’. Contrasting to Christians’ belief, Islam says that Jesus was only the Messenger of Allah, and that he was not divine. Islam does believe in Jesus’ virgin birth but Islam denies that Jesus was ever crucified or resurrected, or that he ever atoned for the sins of mankind; it especially scorns any notions that Jesus is to be worshiped or prayed to.

A Swedish theologian says, “"The problem is descriptions of crucifixions are remarkably absent in the antique literature," Samuelsson said in an interview with the UK Daily Telegraph.”The sources where you would expect to find support for the established understanding of the event really don't say anything."

Share your knowledge about this whole debate. What is your belief about Jesus’ crucifixion?

This discussion is not intended to hurt anyone’s emotions. The whole purpose is to come to a conclusion that is understandable and logical.

 

[speedy]

I am Christian and I strong believed that Jesus crucified and risen. We are all aware that every religion teaches different things. But even before I know how to read the Bible, I can feel that Jesus is real and HE is my God. I can feel Him, I talk to Him and I know He is just there watching. For Christian, Bible is the Word of God. It was written by inspiration and with the guidance of the Holy Spirit. I personally believed that Jesus is not only a messenger. He is the God who don't have a name in the Old Testament. As we know in the Old Testament God was called in many names like Jehovah, Elohim, El Shaddai, and many more. Muslim who believed in Allah and non- Christian who believed in Jesus are using different language. So, it would be applied to in our faith or any Biblical terms. On my Bible it says and prophesied that " For unto us a child is born, unto us a child is given and His name shall be called Wonderful, Counselor, Almighty God, Everlasting Father and a Prince of Peace and its being fulfilled when Jesus came to the earth. IF you read in the Book of Isaiah chapter 44 -46, it was mentioned there and God declared and told Israel that " No more God besides Him". And if we will read the Book of Revelation where John the Beloved wrote when he was exile in the Island of Patmos and he was in the presence of God while writing the book. It was stated in that book that Jesus will come again descending from heaven with the same manner as He ascended after His death. And He is with His children with His name written on their forehead. So, for me Jesus is God and not only an ordinary man or just a plain messenger. And I strongly believed that He was crucified and there are many evidences that will proof it. That's one of my dream someday to go to Jerusalem and see the grave where Jesus buried and crucified. As people preserved those marks and evidences​

 

[reymartin69]

According to the bible and to my belief, Jesus Christ was crucified and died to save us from our sins. Some religion says that Jesus is just one of the prophets, but think about this, no prophet has died by any means. According to the bible, all of the prophets have not died but was directly taken by GOD. It is the prophecy that the son of God will die to save mankind of all our sins.

 

[ehsanji]

I am Christian and I strong believed that Jesus crucified and risen. We are all aware that every religion teaches different things. But even before I know how to read the Bible, I can feel that Jesus is real and HE is my God. I can feel Him, I talk to Him and I know He is just there watching. For Christian, Bible is the Word of God. It was written by inspiration and with the guidance of the Holy Spirit. I personally believed that Jesus is not only a messenger. He is the God who don't have a name in the Old Testament. As we know in the Old Testament God was called in many names like Jehovah, Elohim, El Shaddai, and many more. Muslim who believed in Allah and non- Christian who believed in Jesus are using different language. So, it would be applied to in our faith or any Biblical terms. On my Bible it says and prophesied that " For unto us a child is born, unto us a child is given and His name shall be called Wonderful, Counselor, Almighty God, Everlasting Father and a Prince of Peace and its being fulfilled when Jesus came to the earth. IF you read in the Book of Isaiah chapter 44 -46, it was mentioned there and God declared and told Israel that " No more God besides Him". And if we will read the Book of Revelation where John the Beloved wrote when he was exile in the Island of Patmos and he was in the presence of God while writing the book. It was stated in that book that Jesus will come again descending from heaven with the same manner as He ascended after His death. And He is with His children with His name written on their forehead. So, for me Jesus is God and not only an ordinary man or just a plain messenger. And I strongly believed that He was crucified and there are many evidences that will proof it. That's one of my dream someday to go to Jerusalem and see the grave where Jesus buried and crucified. As people preserved those marks and evidences​

But I and you we both know that statements you are referring to, that are from the Bible, are not unambiguous. Why do people not talk about the old testaments? This clearly means that Bible is not in its original form.

The point I am trying to make is; how is Bible the word of God when it's not even what it used to be in the times of Jesus Christ (PBUH)?

 

[glen_mark_ledesma]

According to Christians, 2000 years ago the Crucifixion of Jesus took place and he was resurrected on the third day.
Resurrection, according to the new testimonial, means the rising of Christ on the third day after the Crucifixion.

Crucifixion means ‘the act of executing by a method widespread in the ancient world; the victim's hands and feet are bound or nailed to a cross’.

According to Islam, Jesus was sent by Allah, to the people of Israel, with a scripture called ‘Injeel’. Contrasting to Christians’ belief, Islam says that Jesus was only the Messenger of Allah, and that he was not divine. Islam does believe in Jesus’ virgin birth but Islam denies that Jesus was ever crucified or resurrected, or that he ever atoned for the sins of mankind; it especially scorns any notions that Jesus is to be worshiped or prayed to.

A Swedish theologian says, “"The problem is descriptions of crucifixions are remarkably absent in the antique literature," Samuelsson said in an interview with the UK Daily Telegraph.”The sources where you would expect to find support for the established understanding of the event really don't say anything."

Share your knowledge about this whole debate. What is your belief about Jesus’ crucifixion?

This discussion is not intended to hurt anyone’s emotions. The whole purpose is to come to a conclusion that is understandable and logical.

Jesus (PBUH) never died, that's why there is a 2nd coming for Jesus (PBUH). He was sent by God to do the teachings and that makes him a prophet. He was sent in human flesh with the same characteristics of a normal human. So if he was crucified then how come he can go back if he was already killed? He was saved by Allah (God) and take him into the heavens as during the time when he was about to be crucified he prayed and ask "God why have you forsaken me?" and God listened to him and sent him to heavens. That's the reason why there is a second coming for Jesus Christ. Crucifixion has been told by many researchers and even theological researcher and scientists that never happened and the biggest unexplained mystery of crucifixion theory. Even from the exact place that was mentioned on some books claiming that Jesus was crucified, they never found an evidence about that. And I myself saw that documentary from NGC. I was a christian before and I turned to Islam coz I researched about it. Even the bible, the original script was written in Aramaic which is the Classic Arabic whereas the book Quran was written. So the word and language of God is Arabic. So I'd rather believe with the facts coming from God rather than scripts coming from humans. And from Quran, crucifixion was never mentioned which makes me not to believe with it. There is only one god and that is Allah.

 

[fenshu]

as i don't witness it by myself. so i don't know whether it happen or also whether Jesus exist or not. it just know from book.

 

[speedy]

Jesus (PBUH) never died, that's why there is a 2nd coming for Jesus (PBUH). He was sent by God to do the teachings and that makes him a prophet. He was sent in human flesh with the same characteristics of a normal human. So if he was crucified then how come he can go back if he was already killed? He was saved by Allah (God) and take him into the heavens as during the time when he was about to be crucified he prayed and ask "God why have you forsaken me?" and God listened to him and sent him to heavens. That's the reason why there is a second coming for Jesus Christ. Crucifixion has been told by many researchers and even theological researcher and scientists that never happened and the biggest unexplained mystery of crucifixion theory. Even from the exact place that was mentioned on some books claiming that Jesus was crucified, they never found an evidence about that. And I myself saw that documentary from NGC. I was a christian before and I turned to Islam coz I researched about it. Even the bible, the original script was written in Aramaic which is the Classic Arabic whereas the book Quran was written. So the word and language of God is Arabic. So I'd rather believe with the facts coming from God rather than scripts coming from humans. And from Quran, crucifixion was never mentioned which makes me not to believe with it. There is only one god and that is Allah.

If we will read our Bible, He was crucified and risen after 3 days and showed up unto His disciples. If you will read the story about doubting Thomas asking if the one who showed if that was really Jesus, He showed him the wound on his hands by the nails when he was crucified. He was dead but risen from the dead and ascend to heaven. We can't out powered God and even he raised Lazarus from dead. Jesus died to redeemed us from our sins. He shed His own flood to redeemed His people. Remember in Old Testament, people were having a burnt offering using the animal's blood but still people keep on sinning. So, God cloth himself as a human to be an example to us and became an offering to redeemed the world.

 

[jethro64]

well I'm with speedy.
Jesus, with no doubt, has been crucified, died, laid behind a stone/grave, and has been risen from the dead after three days, and is now in heaven preparing room for those who really believe and accepted him as ones own Lord and Saviour.
If you're going research if he really died, you might better ask why did he died? who's the real reason why he sacrificed his life, and receive all those pains and hardship. Can a man really endure that kind of pain, difficulties and trials?
Jesus is not human, he is God, he became human to show how great his love is, for us. He died on that cross, to pay for our sins, and so that we wouldn't go to hell anymore.

 

[armarasrar1]

Well I think there is a good available answer given by Dr. Zakir Naik and I think the CD is Available on the Internet you can see that

 

[rob50]

According to Christians, 2000 years ago the Crucifixion of Jesus took place and he was resurrected on the third day.
Resurrection, according to the new testimonial, means the rising of Christ on the third day after the Crucifixion.

Crucifixion means ‘the act of executing by a method widespread in the ancient world; the victim's hands and feet are bound or nailed to a cross’.

According to Islam, Jesus was sent by Allah, to the people of Israel, with a scripture called ‘Injeel’. Contrasting to Christians’ belief, Islam says that Jesus was only the Messenger of Allah, and that he was not divine. Islam does believe in Jesus’ virgin birth but Islam denies that Jesus was ever crucified or resurrected, or that he ever atoned for the sins of mankind; it especially scorns any notions that Jesus is to be worshiped or prayed to.

A Swedish theologian says, “"The problem is descriptions of crucifixions are remarkably absent in the antique literature," Samuelsson said in an interview with the UK Daily Telegraph.”The sources where you would expect to find support for the established understanding of the event really don't say anything."

Share your knowledge about this whole debate. What is your belief about Jesus’ crucifixion?

This discussion is not intended to hurt anyone’s emotions. The whole purpose is to come to a conclusion that is understandable and logical.

i dont know it I m not a christian btw according to relics he was crucified

 

[MsRaintree]

I believe in what was written in the bible. Jesus was sent by God the Father to redeem us from sins and that is through His crucifixion. This is what I believed in. Different religions have different teachings, this is the reason why sometimes I decline to listen to it. In respect of other religious beliefs, I do not judge nor make any comment about the crucifixion anymore. This is just my piece, if I believe in Jesus being crucified to redeem us from sins, allow me to have it in me and my co-believers. If you do not believe in it as it was taught in you, I will let you have it. For me, the most important thing is that, if you are a good Muslim, Buddhist, Prrotestant, Catholic and all kinds of believers of other religions, continue being so. What we will be judged upon is the way we lived our lives and how we served our purpose on earth. Whether we believe in different doctrines as long as we believe that in the end, there is only one God who wants us to live in peace and harmony, it is the only thing that matters.

 

[pinoycity]

Well, I guess, since the crucifixion happened 2000 years ago, people are becoming unsure if this really happened. This would not have been the case, centuries ago. But then, for us believers, as they say, no proof is needed. But to non-believers, no explanation is enough.

 

[arnelia]

Yes as i read in our BiBLE JESUS crucified.he save us in our sins.what ever some people say i do belive in our bible.