Who would win?

[Hailzterina]

Who would win in a fight, assuming that both players have an equal amount of Pking knowledge and are both experienced in Pking.

Player A:

Attack Level: 80
Strength Level: 99
Defense Level: 70
Prayer Level: 43
Constitution: 90
Combat Level: 103

Player B:

Ranged Level: 99
Defense Level: 99
Prayer Level: 44
Constitution: 94
Combat Level: 102

Please state why the person you have chosen would win and what the person could do to increase their chances of winning. I hope 6-7 people give their input and that this thread doesn't die without being answered by an ample amount of people. Thanking you,

Hailzterina

 

[Maxie]

Everything depends on luck if the skill differences are not obvious, I would say Player A though, but it do depend on what items he got etc.

 

[Manatee]

So player b has no attack or strength?
Most rangers now a days almost always pull out a spec wep.

 

[Automatic]

I'd say A, you just gave the stats with no armour meaning that they're boxing. A melee guy can't beat a ranger boxing

 

[Godsword]

So player b has no attack or strength?
Most rangers now a days almost always pull out a spec wep.

Yep it's called a d bow.

 

[Manatee]

So player b has no attack or strength?
Most rangers now a days almost always pull out a spec wep.

Yep it's called a d bow.

smart ass.
Im talking about a melee weapon.

;D

 

[Hailzterina]

I'd say A, you just gave the stats with no armour meaning that they're boxing. A melee guy can't beat a ranger boxing

They're not boxing..

Player A is wearing Full Rune and Player B is playing Full Black d'hide + archer's helm. Who'd win?

So player b has no attack or strength?
Most rangers now a days almost always pull out a spec wep.

Yep it's called a d bow.

smart ass.
Im talking about a melee weapon.

;D

The Ranger is using Morgan Javelin's as spec wep... who'd win?

 

[Manatee]

The ranger has a good chance with the use of good bolts + morg javs.

So i'd put my bet on the ranger.

 

[Trypod007]

I think B would win because 99 def and A would not be able to hit that high and 99 ranged could do some good damage but it all depends if they have the best stuff for their Levels.

 

[Relapse]

If they are both wearing the maxed possible gear they can, definitely player b. 99 range and defence using dragon/diamond bolts with a dark bow for spec wep.

 

[Joel_mybb_import15139]

I'd say player B, that 99 range with all possible range bonus' added would pierce through that 70 defense like candy along with D'bow to finish him off.

 

[Trypod007]

I'd say player B, that 99 range with all possible range bonus' added would pierce through that 70 defense like candy along with D'bow to finish him off.

Yeh nice call.

 

[Tyler-]

Player b could only win if they got a luck spec..

 

[Hailzterina]

Thanks so much everyone for your opinions! I really appreciate it!

 

[Relapse]

Player b could only win if they got a luck spec..

could say the same about player a? player b would outlast them player a though also