Dog shock collars?

Philly

Power member.
Joined
Mar 18, 2011
Posts
16,093
Reacts
0
Reputation
0
Credits
420
What is your opinion? Are they inhumane or what? I want to know your opinion on the matter.
 
It works lol ;)
I don't really think it's inhuman lol
 
I think at first it's inhuman because they will get shocked but they will learn so it becomes good. It does work though
 
It depends on your intentions. If the collar gives just a little shock that doesnt physically hurt the pet than i think it alright. If the collar has a high voltage then i think it is wrong since it is physically hurting the pet.
 
Yeah it depends on the power of it. Strong ones are inhumane but just a little shock will teach them pretty fast.
 
The thing is shock colors for boundary reasons are alright, but barking reasons are inhumane because it's how they communicate.

Would you want to be shocked every time you said something.
 
Reaper said:
The thing is shock colors for boundary reasons are alright, but barking reasons are inhumane because it's how they communicate.

Would you want to be shocked every time you said something.
Click to expand...
I agree but some dogs bark all day and night, so some might need it.
 
Reaper said:
The thing is shock colors for boundary reasons are alright, but barking reasons are inhumane because it's how they communicate.

Would you want to be shocked every time you said something.
Click to expand...

I guess you have never met a dog that barks and doesn't stop. Meaning the dog sits there and barts, and howls for numerous hours! A little barking is fine,m but when they bark for hours straight that is completely different, and that is when action should be taken.
 
That is so messed up i treat my dog as if she were a person i would never do that im not Michael vick. can you say cruel and unusual punishment?
 
FBI said:
That is so messed up i treat my dog as if she were a person i would never do that im not Michael vick. can you say cruel and unusual punishment?
Click to expand...

Really? Most shock callers are no worse than touching your tongue to a nine volt battery.
 
Reaper said:
Just shove some battery's in his mouth with a Muzzle then, save money.
Click to expand...

No because that is a constant shock rather than just a very minor shock when barking.
 
If your dog constantly barks I have no problem with these, but if it is just because you want your dog to be completely silent that isn't right. My dog is really good though, he almost never barks or anything.
 
i dont think they are humane on dogs. on people their grate entertainment
 
Lmao, I don't understand how some of you think. Like seriously how is it inhumane when your dog barks and you tell it to stop and it doesn't for hours and hours and hours 100% straight without considering stopping. I never once meant to put it on a already good dog that never barks. This is strictly for dogs that need to stop barking so much.
 
I think bigger dogs that bark allot is ok to use on. But DEF not for small dogs like pugs :p
 
Philly said:
Lmao, I don't understand how some of you think. Like seriously how is it inhumane when your dog barks and you tell it to stop and it doesn't for hours and hours and hours 100% straight without considering stopping. I never once meant to put it on a already good dog that never barks. This is strictly for dogs that need to stop barking so much.
Click to expand...

There's some crazy people out there.
 
Philly said:
Lmao, I don't understand how some of you think. Like seriously how is it inhumane when your dog barks and you tell it to stop and it doesn't for hours and hours and hours 100% straight without considering stopping. I never once meant to put it on a already good dog that never barks. This is strictly for dogs that need to stop barking so much.
Click to expand...

There has to be a point in the lifetime where you bought the dog knowing it barked a lot, or a point where he never barked as much.

It's the owners fault, something the owner did to it maybe (abuse, trauma) , that makes the dog bark more then it used to or start barking more.

So the shock collar shouldn't be.
 
Shock collars are completely inhumane. You should be able to control your dog without administering electric shocks to it. If you can't, you don't deserve to own a dog. Anyone who uses one on their dog should have one put on themselves.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Featured

• General Discussion
• Inactive FK Username Requests

Share this page

Back
Top