Should PHENOM be allowed back?

Should Phneom be allowed back?

  • Yes

    Votes: 45 50.0%

  • No

    Votes: 38 42.2%

  • Maybe

    Votes: 7 7.8%
  • Total voters
    90
Just because he admitted to it doesn't make him a changed man, or even worthy of being thought of for a second chance. He broke the rules, in black and white. He may have been a nice member, or a good friend, but once a rule is broken you just can't give in and give someone another chance Philly. It makes you look extremely weak to the rest of the site. If he comes back, who's to say you shouldn't just lift all the bans? (besides Tehstickle, never lift that one.) Philly I'm just confused as to why you put this as a poll, you make it seem like one of those needy facebook pages. "Like if u love ur mom", no. These votes are totally biased due to the fact most of them are his friends, and I mean nothing harsh to you Phenom. I don't know you, but this is my generalized answer of no.
 
Wow this is become awful close. Most of Phenom's friends voted yes while others who thought it through said no. Why is there a maybe?
 
Philly said:
Keep the votes coming, its really close.
Click to expand...

Why is this thread even open? Like honestly? If he gets voted back, then we have to let all the other scammers back out of 'fairness'. When DWC was open, if you wanted to get unbanned and thrown in DWC you had to give back what you scammed within 3 days from the incident. It's clearly not 3 days.


As for everyone else who wants him back i'm dissapointed, you look passed the fact that he turbo'd members because he's your "friend" so you want him back because he's your friend. If you were the one who got turbo'd you sure would not want him back. He's my friend and all but he broke the rules. Phenom + turboing tags (results in banned forever) = Perm-ban forever. It's simple math.


I'll start getting the welcome party ready for Moon's arrival.
 
yes yes yes yes he should why not? He's a human you know? and this is a site, who cares what he has done. That's the past, the poor woman deserves another chance even though I don't know'em
 
You guys there is a difference between turboeing and scamming he never scammed he turboed and he was the only one who had the balls to admit to it. I'm nor have i talked to him once but from what everyone has said about him seems true, Hes never scammed at all, Always been legit and will continue. When you turbo a tag some people get a rush and want to keep doing it, its like an addiction but looks like hes trying to stop. So why not give him 1 more chance when we gave DURA(That scamming piece of shit) 5 chances and he scammed.
 
1. Comparing turboing to a drug addiction is a bit much
2. Turboing is just as bad as scamming.
 
I agree with both sides, I think bans should be final, but they haven't been in the past. Dura was allowed back numerous times and few people even liked him nor was he helpful at all, unless you were selling something. . No hate to dura, but he was first to come to mind, many others have been in the same situation.
From my experience phenom was always really chill and helped quite a bit. Because of that is why I think it would be fair for him to come back. But as I understand both sides, I respect either decision, it's ultimately up to you Philly.
 
Turbo-ing is stealing, which is scamming. I don't understand why you'd make a thread about this Philly, FK was known as the site didn't have a high amount of turboers. And if one was caught, it was a immediate life time ban, I believe.
 
There would be more "No" votes if some people didn't misclick like Fear. He shouldn't be allowed back.
 
Kev said:
@Joey Because you're stupid as fuck. Phenom has turboed plenty of tags and turboing is pretty much the same as scamming.
Click to expand...
So..................
Should most of the community be banned? Cause at least he owns up to it.
 
He still did it and still DOES it. Him and Doctor do it. If you let him back, you may aswell bring everyone back lol.
 
Megaman said:
So..................
Should most of the community be banned? Cause at least he owns up to it.
Click to expand...

Owning up to it does not sugar coat the fact that he did it. If you turbo a user's Gamertag, you are in fact scamming.

Sanc also made a valid point. Deal With Caution no longer exists, so users will not be made aware of Phenom's past. Also, users are banned permanently with no chance of return now that DWC is gone.

This whole thread is favoring Phenom. If he deserves an additional chance, then others deserve an additional chance. And if that is the case, we may as allow "turboing."
 

I agree with Jason and all the others that have voted no.

It clearly states in the rules no turboing, I'm sure he broke that more than once. So why allow him back?
He may act all nice and rosey now, But what will happen in the future?
 
I vote yes because he was always legit and nice.
That is my personal opinion.
He is just man enough to admit to the shit he did.
unlike 50% of members on FK that turbo.
And PLEASE stop quoting Kev.
I don't want to read his shit.
Nothing he says is worthy of a quote.
 
Megaman said:
So..................
Should most of the community be banned? Cause at least he owns up to it.
Click to expand...

Like what other people said, admitting to it doesn't make it any better.
Would it be better if I scammed someone and then admitted?
Would it be better if I murdered someone and then admitted?


Man? Doesn't take much guts to post something on the Internet lol.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.